The library has wide range of local history books including books on the history of Babylon and the history of Long Island . The library has a collection of Babylon High School yearbooks dating back to 1938. The library maintains the following newspapers on microfilm:
| South Side Signal | 07/1869-12/1920 |
| Babylon Leader | 01/1921-09/1958 |
| Babylon Town Leader | 10/1958-10/1966 |
| Babylon Beacon | 04/1967-08/1972 |
| Beacon | 08/1972-12/2009 |
The South Side Signal from 1869-1879 and the Babylon Beacon from 1967-1972 and from 2010-2018 were digitized and are part of the NYS Historic Newspapers.